Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows *Warning - Thread WILL Contain Spoilers*

Am I the only one who thinks this book was about as bad as the new Versace ads? I mean, I liked it a lot, and it made me feel sympathy for Snape, but the epilogue just RUINED it! Harry and Ginny just didn't need to be together (a better match would be Harry and Luna). And how could they be so mean as to name that poor child Albus Severus. That just did it for me.
The epilogue was really great :heart: I think I'm about the only one who likes it.. its like a very cliched fairy tale ending.. after all this violence and turbulence in the past, I think its great to have this calming refreshing ending ,where all is well and they had a wonderful life , it makes you feel happy that these characters you've been with for so long are still alive. Well for me anyways :lol: I liked the names but albus severus :unsure::unsure: oh no.. the rest is fine I love how it shows them interacting with the kids.. you'd never really thought of Harry as a father figure or Ron or Hermione ^_^ Personally the epilogue for me was a very cheesy happy ending to end such a dark series :heart:
 
I AM DONE WITH IT AND I AM SOOOO SO SO HAPY!!!

l personally loved the epilogue... i think i actually read it quite a few times... :blush:
although it was pretty predictable, harry and Ginny, Ron and Hermione, the names of the kids (james and albus).... i wouldnt have guessed Severus though i think it made sense...
i am glad that the "truth" about Dumbledore came finally out and we could really know if he had lied or not, what was his relationship with Snape afterall, pretty much everything that during the book had been bothering me (dumbledore was always one of my fav characters, and jsut doubting wheter he was or not a good person after all made me not like the book as i was reading it) But i love it now...i cant wait to see the last 2 movies left and i really hope they make some really good ones out of these last two wonderful books!!

i`ve read about this Potter Encyclopedia and it came to mind mind these short films about the matrix that i saw not too long ago. they were manga and anime films that had to do with the movie without being strictly related with the plot of the films... different characters and diferent moments.
i think it would be cool if they did something quite like that, and the shortfilms featured details that are not shown throughout the books. Parallel experiences and stuff... in any case... jsut a thought :P
 
I'm not sure if this has been posted. Daniel Radcliffe's interview/opinion on Deathly Hallows?

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20044270_20044274_20048635,00.html

ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: There was a picture that circulated this week, of you in a cap, holding a copy of Deathly Hallows...
DANIEL RADCLIFFE: Oh, yes. I think it was probably at Lord's Cricket Ground [in St. John's Wood, London]. Which was a great day. That wasn't actually my copy. A guy had asked me to sign it, and of course, somebody took a photo. It looked like I was about to start reading. So that became, The moment when Harry Potter started reading.
When did you in fact get to start reading it?
I actually wrote, in the front of my book, the exact time of me starting to read it. I think it was 9:30 at night on the 22nd of July, which was the day before my [18th] birthday. I read two chapters on that day, which wasn't very much at all, of course. About page 30, I got to. Then I actually didn't get to read [any of] it again for another couple of days. I started again on the 24th and 25th, and over those two days or so, I seemed to completely demolish it. I read 350 pages in one day at one point.
What surprised or shocked you the most?
Dobby's death. He's always been a comic character, in some ways. And that's what makes it so powerful, I suppose. I'm sure Jo's had that planned for a very long time. That was one of the bits that made me surprised. One of my other theories had been that Snape would end up being a sort of tragic hero, and so I was pleased to see that one in fact come through. That [idea] was given to me by a guy interviewing me, a while ago. He said he thought that would be the case. And I thought, Oh, that's very good.
You finish Half-Blood Prince feeling Dumbledore was a fool to trust Snape. But I finished Deathly Hallows feeling maybe Snape was not well served by trusting Dumbledore, and that Dumbledore used him pretty ruthlessly. There are so many ways in which Rowling changes our picture of Dumbledore by the end of Deathly Hallows. He's got even more flaws than you'd expect.
I have to say it matched some of my predictions [about Dumbledore]. I'd sort of thought of a couple of those things. I'd imagined we would see a darker side to Dumbledore. But I didn't know in what way. I was incredibly moved by it, the whole thing.
Any other surprising bits of closure for you?
Another thing has confused me for so long. It was in the fourth film script, and it was in the book as well, of course. When we rehearsed the scene, it was the scene in which Harry had come back from the maze, and his blood has gone into Voldemort and so on. I could never understand why there was a line in the book that said, Dumbledore looked at the scar on Harry's arm with — I think the phrase is something like, He looked at it with something close to triumph in his eyes. I've never understood that. I could never get it. No one could. No one knew. And of course, it turns out it's because Dumbledore realized that as well as Voldemort being inside Harry, Harry's blood was now inside Voldemort. Therefore his mother Lily's blood was also inside Voldemort, which obviously plays a huge part in [Deathly Hallows]. That explained a lot to me.

Were you glad to find out that Harry, Ron, and Hermione all survive?
I was, actually. Weirdly enough, I think that's the bravest thing she could've done. I was convinced for about two years that Harry would die.
Why?
I just felt it was the only way she could end it. But then, within the last six months, it suddenly occurred to me that that was far too obvious. She had to find a cleverer way of doing it. And indeed she did. With Ron and Hermione, I really liked the epilogue. I think a few people might've been not so keen on that. But I actually really, really liked it.
In a way, Harry actually does die, because he believes he's going to die. There's a profoundly, existentially lonely passage in the chapter when he prepares to let himself be killed.
In a way, the time between Harry learning he has to die and actually dying —
Or believing he's dying...
That time wasn't short enough to be painless. But it wasn't long enough for him to find complete acceptance within it either. He struggles to find acceptance. Ultimately, he finds a sort of acceptance. But he's not necessarily reconciled with the idea of it. He knows he has to do it, but he's still scared. I just can't wait to be able to film it. I think Jo has given me, once again, an amazing opportunity to step up. So hopefully I'll be able to.
What did you do when you finished reading Deathly Hallows?
I was in a car at the time. I had my iPod in, and I was listening to Sigur Rós. I don't know if you know them. They're a band who do sort of instrumental music, but it's just amazing. I think they're from Scandinavia somewhere. They've got an album called Takk...I was listening to, and it's very, very appropriate [for the end of Deathly Hallows]. I was listening to it and I remember I was sort of turned away from everybody else in the car, just so I could be in my own little world when I read it. What did I do when I finished? I think I just put the book down and carried on listening to the music. Just looked out of the car window, 'cause I couldn't think of what else to do. I'm still struggling to really take it in. It doesn't leave you in a hurry.
 
^ Thanks for that, its nice to hear is opinion, I wonder if he cried? There were some very emotional parts! It must have been so weird for him to read that because hes been doing it for so long, playing that character that he must care about what happens to him in the end (Harry)

I would like to hear Rupert Grints opinion too:blush:
 
I agree with what he said here:

Were you glad to find out that Harry, Ron, and Hermione all survive?
I was, actually. Weirdly enough, I think that's the bravest thing she could've done. I was convinced for about two years that Harry would die.


Why?
I just felt it was the only way she could end it. But then, within the last six months, it suddenly occurred to me that that was far too obvious. She had to find a cleverer way of doing it. And indeed she did. With Ron and Hermione, I really liked the epilogue. I think a few people might've been not so keen on that. But I actually really, really liked it.

I liked the ending, and there were enough painful deaths (Hedwig, Dobby, Fred, Snape, Lupin&Tonks :cry:) that getting rid of Harry or one of the trio would have been too much to bear. :lol: I like the semi-happy ending. :blush:

I liked the lighthearted moments, like when Fred and George joked about George's ear, and Harry's birthday when Ron gave him that book (:lol:) and when Harry and Ginny kiss.

I also loved the parts in the book that showed Ron and Hermione's feelings and relationship towards each other, especially the chapter where Ron comes back and saves Harry's life, only to be yelled at by Hermione.

Another exciting part was when Harry found the Hufflepuff cup, the events leading up to it and what happened afterwards was a thrill.

Dobby's death was so touching and sad. :cry: I also wish that JK would have elaborated more on Fred and George, and it was terrible to kill off Fred. Poor George. :cry:

There were many other moments that were amazing, including Harry's death march and Snape's memories, to name the most prominent in my mind at the moment. :heart::cry: I cried when Harry told his son that Snape was "the bravest man he knew."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
^ I know, I wanted to see Georges reaction, I think if you kill Fred you've effectivley killed George too; so sad.
 
Yes... :cry: If you watch Fred's death from Harry's angle it's not that tragic, but if you think about George... that's so horrible:cry: The same with Lupin and Tonks... their death means that little Teddy have to grew up without his parents.:cry:
 
^ I know, that was so tragic Lupin had been depressed and not himself for so long and then finally everything was going ok...
 
^And JKR wrote they were peaceful-looking:cry: this made me think how beautiful life they would have together with their child.:(

And I love your new quote. One of my faves too. For me its about Draco, though I know its rather about Snape.:blush: But I really hope Draco's life became happier.
 
Me too, it wouldve been nice if we couldve learned more about Draco and what he was thinking at some points of the book because I truly think he was petrified (but still that he wanted to be on the death eaters side?); the epilogue for him was good at least where it said he nodded at Ron & Hermione- made me feel bad for him that maybe he wasnt so bad afterall? But at least his mother cared for him if not the others in his family (Bellatrix etc)
 
I loved him in the epilogue too, he was the best part of it or the only good one:lol: Maybe he didn't know if he wants to be deatheater or not. He was so young and because of his family he hadn't really got a chance to choose. Though he wasn't a saint at all, but I think serving Voldemort for while made him a better persone, he learnt what fears means... If Voldemort wouldn't be that cruel to him and to his family maybe he would be different in the end...
 
It's horrible. :cry: I think that's why both Lupin+Tonks' and Fred's deaths were the most awful. They all left somebody who depended on them behind.

While it is sad for everyone that Fred died, it totally destroys George because the twins were like one. Always together. A part of one another. Inseparable. Fred's death separated them once and for all. :cry:

And Lupin and Tonks left the baby behind with no parents, so the child is the one suffering the most. :(

And I know that people have said that Hedwig was just a bird, but for people who have pets, it's incredibly sad. If a dog dies, people say it's "just a dog," but if you ever owned a dog you would no how untrue that statement is. It's not "just a dog."

And it's not "just a bird" either. I love animals and was really sad to see Hedwig go. :(

And Dobby. :cry:
 
Also, I liked that it turned out that Dumbledore was already dying, although that sounds quite harsh when put that way. :lol: Many fans suspected that Snape was acting on Dumbledore's orders but him being killed when he was going to die anyway was a twist that I didn't see coming.

Another part I liked in the book was the time that Harry, Ron, and Hermione spent at No. 12, Grimmauld Place. I never thought I would find myself liking Kreacher. :lol:

And lastly, Bathilda's Secret was a terrible chapter, IMO. :innocent: I hated the whole Godric's Hollow bit. Very creepy indeed. :blink:
 
I did like the part where they were camping and taking turns wearing the locket.

Like someone else said on this thread, it really was a psychological challenge more than anything else.
 
^That's a good way to put it. :flower: It was psychological, wasn't it?

I liked it how Ron couldn't live without food and was always grumpy and complaining about it. I think that would've been me if I were in the same situation. :lol:

I think I mentioned it before, but the chapter where Harry was looking at Snape's memories in the pensieve was brilliant. It explained everything and was written incredibly. I felt so bad for Snape. :(
I think that it also explained why Voldemort told Lily to get out of the way and that she didn't have to die. He did sort of take into consideration Snape's pleas, but apparently not enough. :doh:
 
I thought that was interesting too because Voldemort actually respected Snape enough to take his requests into consideration.

It makes him a bit more human.
 
Thankyou for posting the interview with Dan! Very sweet how he had his little moment at the end. I can imagine Sigur Ros would have amplified the emotions that he would have felt at the end.
 
I didn't feel enough information was given about Draco's future life :lol: If the predictability continued even with his life, we can probably safely assume he married Pansy... but...
 
I did like the part where they were camping and taking turns wearing the locket.

Like someone else said on this thread, it really was a psychological challenge more than anything else.
I suppose she meant it as a plot device to push Ron to abandon them but it smacked rather too much of LOTR with Frodo & Sam having to wear the One Ring around their necks and it's negative effects on them.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

New Posts

Forum Statistics

Threads
213,105
Messages
15,209,445
Members
87,060
Latest member
sffr
Back
Top