If she were winking, I'd mistake this for an I-D cover. Even the layout screams I-D
I would've loved this if it were in color. The filter takes away the energy of the pose.
Maybe this is the new VI direction. Commercial and very subdued. I just hope it doesn't end up looking like those Indie Magazines that are so obsessed with the youth (I-D, Dazed, +++)
Also, I hope that it is in this thread that we could finally put to an end the idea that when a person criticizes a Non-Meisel cover, it automatically means that the only reason why he/she doesn't like it is because it wasn't shot by Meisel. "If it were shot by Meisel people would go crazy over it." No. A bad cover is a bad cover, regardless of the photographer.