The biggest problem with the cover is that the girls all have the same hair and makeup, and even their dresses sort of blend together. The September 2004 cover (and the current September Vogue Italia cover) had Karen Elson in a dark lip and hair half pulled up, while Gisele has a deep side part and natural lip, a couple of the models have middle parts and smoky eyes. And of course the color of their dresses were all very different.. It's really not cute to have them all look the same, like they're little children wearing matching sweaters.