Much like everyone else Jennifer isn't necessarily my favorite actress, however she looks pretty decent here. I like the spirit they captured in celebrating their anniversary, so good job on that. But I just wish Meisel had a hand in this as well. So many classic September Issues he's shot through the years would have been a nice to see him celebrated.
In regards to Nicole who I would slightly preferred over Jennifer already had this sort of treatment in the past. If recall correctly they did something similar in 2003, she was shot by by the likes of Helmut Newton, Irving Penn, Annie, and Craig McDean. So I'm not exactly messing her, having the opportunity to be photographed by Helmut and Irving alone is significant enough in my opinion.