I know this part should be on
The Business of Magazines Thread but since it was brought up...
From my understanding of their circulation average per year:
a. Column 1 indicates the year of publication
b. Column 2 indicates the average of issues printed
c. Column 3 indicates the average issues sold in France
d. Column 4 indicates the average issues sold Internationally
2010 - 215,349 | 121,055 | 39,680
2011 - 223 263 | 121,103 | 39,869
2012 - 221 856 | 122,618 | 36,168
2013 - 219 900 | 118,024 | 32,477
2014 - 219,930 | 121,871 | 35,426 (DSH)
OJD, Vogue Paris Media Kit
I think the sales are indeed okay because it grew instead of fell even after the departure of Carine. There was a demise on the year 2013 (especially some issues from this year were really stale and uninspiring). Well at least, they got back up during 2014.
Although, can someone clarify the 2014 data. It is on their 2015 media kit so it has to be the data for 2014 but on OJD, it states 2013/2014. So I'm not really sure.