Pardon my grouchy side for Post #1588... Big Nay! Jeffrey Campbell shoes and Big Nay! Mia Botticelli. If we're doing "yay or nay and which?", get neither. Or, okay... if you were forced to choose one of the other, MAYBE the second oxford sandals. Both are horrible shoes. People usually request to see them being worn by models to see if they look better when worn. Me, however... I know ugly when I see it. The second ones have at least some resemblance of chic style. Too bad they aren't lovely enough for me to fall in love with them. Big Nay to both shoes, but I would choose the second if choosing between two ugly shoes was the difference between life and death.
Bad girl with a touch of cute. Big Yay! to the cropped leather jacket (Post #1594). Rather than that horrid polka dot top (I don't hate polka dots) and those ugly jeans, I'd probably see this with a short frilly dress. Pretty cool in my view.