JJbunny
Eyeliners solely are too harsh on already "flat" asian eyes, they look very vulgar dramatically lined and un-smudged w/o mascara (may I say). I have to say, eyeliners alone, and to a worse extent on lower lashline/waterline does NOT make eyes look better!! We are unlike women of other race, they can get away with just lined eyes, but we can not due to our bone structure. Mascara looks more soft, natural, opens up the eyes, makes it look very spry. Even if you want the smokey look, smudge the liner, AND MASCARA.
Hope this does not offend, and helped