Aw man.
I kind of saw it coming though.. I think that it would've been somewhat humiliating not to give the position to Alt, whose popularity, buzz and influence have increased dramatically in the last years. But I think it's the kind of title meant to last for a very short time, from months to a handful (2-3) years.. just to reduce the impact of Carine's departure, both in the business environment and also in the magazine.. I think the people at CN must be fully aware of Alt's clear inferiority as a EIC (in comparison to Carine and probably the other people at other editions of Vogue).