Last season's Chloe was so badly bashed on tfs, yet net-a-porter and Barney's are now featuring it in a big way, and it's influenced a number of SS08 collections, from COS to Martine Sitbon. No one complained that it wasn't gorgeous, just that it wasn't "Chloe"! Well, when Nicholas G started at Balenciaga with the surreal frills and feathers, it wasn't Balenciaga either. Or Galliano's early days at Dior. Or Mccartney at Chloe. I'd rather judge the designer by his/her talent than by some idea of a particular "style" the house is supposed to produce into infinity.
I would have been curious to see if he is capable of leading into a new and prescient direction this season, something new and unexpected, even the coming look for FW08, but it seems he's caved in to a half-baked chiffony version of Chloe and those paint strokes. Some nice pieces here and there, but just not the same powerful coherence and energy he produced last season. I hope he gets a stab at the next collection with a bit more confidence and support!