I love the lighting, the colors, the detail, and I think the clothing looks great. Some shots are very cool (Lily D holding arm, girls walking dog)
But I agree, the girls are indistinguishable from one another (which might be intentional, but doesn't look so good) and look far too mannequin-y and plastic (again, might be the style they were going for in this campaign, but I think it's ill-suited for the collection.)
Overall, I like it. Over-retouched, though.