I actually prefer the Captain trousers right now to the distressed boyfriend jeans (I lived in those last summer). I was previously addicted to J Brand - I had so many of those in every shape from skinny to super flare, though I never tried their shorts - but as soon as I tried my first pair of C/E I was hooked. I also am loving the Scout short this summer. I read your blog entry, and oddly enough, I am somewhat the opposite of you atm. I had never tried inexpensive denim before, and was quite surprised to find an amazing pair of shorts at Forever 21 for something like $25. I wouldn't necessarily take them over my C/E, but it's a great feeling every once in a while to find such a steal.