To me you've missed the point: all he asserts is that as a first issue revamp it hits, for the most part, predictable notes. However specific and appropriate the choice of cover model and/or photographer (and the Pilati etc.) may be the fact is that it's been generally done somany times before the effect is muted. No one's asking for a genius but the idea isn't a stretch of any kind. (...)
no i think i got it right ...
with your relecture i'm sure about it ...
all is saying is
déjà entendu ...
we see always the same things in every magazines ... blablabla ...so what ? where's the analysis ?!
i'm not going on TI to read what i can think about by myself ... I go overthere to see (more than read) interesting things ....
I, myself, was disappointed by his review of the magazine .... 2 or 3 quotes from WWD don't make everything ....
As for the offered alternative that is a false dilemma unless you're honestly saying that the entire fashion photography industry is split between M&M/I&V/Testino/Miesel-types and guerrilla photographers with a MySpace portfolio. If so I suggest people worry less about finding fresh model faces and get obsessive about photographers before the sector collapses

.
i'm seriously thinking this, yes ...

search a thread i opened a while ago ... about who could be the new
Meisel or something ...
and just go through the ad campains threads ... you'll see by yourself ...
i already complained about these photog' and i'm always happy when a
fresh photog' is getting the cover ... but it's not often !
Kate is predictable because she's a warholesque icon ... and because
[Baron] has worked with kate for years, one of the first people to work with her.(...)september is the big one, I'm sure Fabien called kate and asked her to do it.
but of course, now, you can hide all those "oh-so-bad-commercial-mainstream" magazines and buy some stuff like Crash, Preen etc. .... that are very good, for sure .... but that i don't often hear about on TI - by the way
.....
I hardly know a darn thing about fashion photography but from reading tFS for a few months I could have come up with the same combo and then worked in the Warhol idea from a quick look at a Wiki article or two

. (Maybe tFS members are just that good?)
always hated those kind of arguments ...
you could, but you didn't ...
but complaining about the new revamped ITW is, I'm sure, the Hype thing to do ....

until i see it, i won't !