Yay or Nay?

[shoegal87]

nay to the skirt

 

[John_M.]

The skirt in Post #96 is more like a mini skirt attached to a fairly modest mini skirt (if you think there is a such thing as a modest mini skirt). I've said in the past that what some people call layering is what I call trying too hard. Well... the deal breaker is the mini skirt attached to this skirt. It's a very cute skirt, so I'll give it some leeway. Okay... because it's still a cute skirt, I'm inclined to go (VERY slight) Nay! I don't want to say "maybe" because this is "Yay or Nay," not "Yay, Nay, or Maybe?"

It's a fail skirt, but not by much. So dress and shop confidently!

 

[ediewho]

lightened #80 totally yay!

 

[dauphine]

Madewell Boucle Coat:

madewell.com
I've been waiting for it to go on sale for a looong time, but they only have it left now in a large, which I definitely am not, but perhaps my tailor could do something about that?

 

[John_M.]

Seems comfy, looks nice, so I'll go Yay! for that coat (Post #104). If you can get it tailored and want to get that coat, you have my approval. It's very nice.

 

[Niusity]

Yay! It looks great!

 

[Morana]

Coat looks nice, but after this reviews - nay.

Sizing: Larger than Expected.

I returned this item. Unlike the photo, the design of the jacket is very boxy and does not nip in at the waist. The material is spongy and the buttons don't keep it closed. The material also adds a lot of bulk to an average figure.

Although I love the style and color of this jacket, this item was returned. I thought the material was a little bit below average. The buttons was not very sturdy, it was loose and feels like it will fall off anytime after wear. The jacket had no shape, it was too soft, spongy and bulky. I usually wear size small ( 5ft., 110 lbs) this jacket runs a little big.

shopbop.com

 

[dauphine]

I think after the gorgeous bike ride I just had in 64 degree weather here, I am going to have to nay myself on the coat as well. I'm still saving up for an RO jacket. Pretty sure this is the year it's gonna happen.

 

[bunburyist]

Not gonna buy it because I can't afford it but I'm curious

Nigel Cabourn Naval Parka Beeswax Camo
tresbienshop.net

y/n?

 

[dauphine]

Just a word of advice, waxed canvas is really not that waterproof IRL.
Not that I bought a Barbour jacket this year and then realized that they suck or anything.

 

[chicandcool]

^ Nay sorry. The print is kinda crazy, and I don't mean crazy good.

 

[shoegal87]

^nay

 

[oiselet]

Nay, sorry.

katespade.com

 

[ailin]

oiselet i like them!

 

[ailin]

i feel they would be better without the bow on the front but I like the height and color

 

[PrincessImp.]

Nay to the beeswax camo.
Slight yay to the Kate Spade sandals..love the ribbons but I am iffy about the neon green colour, however it's just me

 

[dauphine]

Yay Katespade! Katespade has some really great stuff for spring.

 

[bunburyist]

Just a word of advice, waxed canvas is really not that waterproof IRL.
Not that I bought a Barbour jacket this year and then realized that they suck or anything.

haha, the site says it is and Cabourn is a bit better made than Barbour but yeah, if I wanted something waterproof I'd probably go with mac.

The print is a bit out there yeah, I doubt I could pull it off but some people definitely could I reckon.

 

[MissyJG]

Nay on the cloud jacket and green sandals!

 

[lifeistiffanyblu]

i love Nigel Cabourn but nay. Yay to the Kate Spade.