The people I watched it with thought Karlie was cute. The dance weirded them out, but I think that got a universal "huh" all around. I told them that she was probably the next angel, and they said she was pretty.
I think she did great in the show, and I wouldn't mind her being an angel. She'll fit in with the new VS line-up, so I hope she gets a contract. She's completely serving it in her new Vogue Italia cover too. If she can do that there, then she can do that with Russell James. None of the other non-angels elicited much of a reaction from my group. I did get asked who Lily was when they showed the Christmas commercial. She looked gorgeous and definitely got double takes.
Surprised that no one's talking about how when the angels did their "Let's talk about one another" segment, the only ones featured were Lily, Erin, Candice, Behati, and Adriana.