Unpopular opinion, but I like Selita. To me, Selita is worthy of being an angel but not a star angel on the level of Heidi, Tyra or Gisele (whether I like them or not, IMO they are the VS superstars - past and present. I am debating if I should add Adriana). In last year's show, I have to admit to being taken aback by Selita's hair - it seemed soccer mom-ish, but really the problem is mine, I have been conditioned to seeing black models in the Pochahantas weaves or with short hair. When I have seen pictures after the fact she looks quite good. Also, she can exude the happy energy without it coming off as being vapid or fake... which brings me to Adriana.
Adriana always looks so vapid, which is saying something because it is not like I am looking a expecting a rocket scientist when I look at a lingerie ad. Having said that, and I cannot explain it, she does have presence in print ads, so I don't begrudge her her success as a VS model. Even her Maybelline ads and commercials draw you in, although the cuts to her are usually a couple of seconds. On the runway, she is either meh (which I think is her signature), but when she does the pointing and kiss blowing, it is painful.
I like Alessandra. She is definitely charming and well-spoken, but she is not one of VS' big personalities. She seems to have some degree of substance to her.