Project Runway Season 5

Forums New posts
doesn't look like we'll see anything too spectacular this time
 
Love the challenge even though it's another reprise of a past challenge, but I'll let it slide since NY at night is so much more inspiring than NY during the day like that challenge back on season 2. But so far I see a lot of ugly going on.

I'm also getting extremely bored of seeing girly little party dresses. It seems like it's all that some of these designers can do.
 
I really hated all the dresses, except like.. one.



Anyway, if I hear Suede talk in third person again I'm going to throw something at my Television.
 
what are they doing keeping stella, blaine, suede and joe in the competition?? what's up with joe?? they haven't devoted a minute to him. and stella's outfit??
 
If Stella doesn't get booted out soon, I honestly don't know if I will continue to watch the show. I can't stand her. In fact, there aren't really any designers who I'm rooting for. For the most part, the designers just don't seem that innovative or talented this season. I'm incredibly disappointed.
 
My random thoughts while watching the runway show...

Terri - I hated the print, there was just too much of it.

Korto - Chic but very bland, there wasn't a whole lot of design involved.

Keith - he got exactly what he aimed for, it looked just like a wet, dirty, destroyed piece of paper in the gutter.

Kenley - that dress was bad enough to negate the perfectly chic dress she did last week. In what world would you EVER use that fabric? Not to mention I see nothing from the picture in it. The judges are out of their goddamn minds to choose it as the winner. What chic NY'er would want to wear a bulbous Polynesian shirt?

Stella - she gets my vote just because she did something other than a flirty little dress. Nothing great, but it stood out for being different.

Leanne - Gorgeous skirt. And she was smart to make the top simple because the end result looked like what people do when they take a runway piece and mix it into their wardrobe, it was an outfit instead of a runway look. She was ROBBED!

Emily - Carmen Miranda would love it....so would Santino.

Jennifer - kind of frumpy, looks a bit Erin Fetherston.

Jerrell - boy needs to tame that ego cause so far his stuff sucks. That was just a poorly made Zac Posen gown.

Joe - the top was ok, and you could see the inspiration. The skirt didn't fit, and the little piece of tulle flying off the back didn't add anything.

Blayne - that kid needs to stop looking at all the pretty colors.

Daniel - It was pretty good, nothing spectacular but it definitely looked like his photo.

Kelli - I kinda liked it actually. It wasn't pretty or cute, it had a bit of edge.

Suede - Baby Phat.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
SO mad that Leanne didn't win! I don't understand why Stella could have gotten through this week...her outfit looked horrendous and so trashy imo.
 
Going by the pics since I haven't seen the episode, but how in the world did Kenley win and Emily get the boot? WHAT? It should've been the other way around if anything. But seriusly, Leanne should've won hands down. The best look no competition. Terri or Stella should've been cut.
 
I'm not really getting all the Stella hate this week. Her outfit was by no means the ugliest, and for all the trashiness of it, it looked really well made.
 
The other way around? I don't think Emily's dress was bad, but winning material? Noway.
 
Aww Emily is so sweet...I can't believe Stella is still around if she makes an outfit out of letha next week and doesn't get kicked out I'm going to be pissed/\.
 
UGH, the judges have seriously lost their taste. I liked Kenley's dress shape, but the print was hideously fug. Leanne obviously deserved to win, I think anyone with two eyes and half a brain realized that. I think Blayne should've gone. His dress was just a fuglier version of Emily's.

But so far this season is better than last. Last season was like pulling teeth for me.

And why does everyone hate Stella? I think she's one of the more tolerable personalities this season.
 
^^I agree! I just made that comment to my mom who was watching with me....what the heck is wrong with the judges? I think the only thing they like are plain, conventional cocktail dresses. Seems like everything else is too complicated for their brains.

And I LOVE Stella! I love her sassy attitude. Despite her endearing quirks, I think she seems pretty normal! She reminds me of a few of my friends who are really sarcastic. Stella is the only 'character' I like this season.

Blayne should have gone. I feel like he's made the same dress for the past three episodes. Something black with some random colors thrown on.
Spike413 said:
My random thoughts while watching the runway show...

Terri - I hated the print, there was just too much of it.

Korto - Chic but very bland, there wasn't a whole lot of design involved.

Keith - he got exactly what he aimed for, it looked just like a wet, dirty, destroyed piece of paper in the gutter.

Kenley - that dress was bad enough to negate the perfectly chic dress she did last week. In what world would you EVER use that fabric? Not to mention I see nothing from the picture in it. The judges are out of their goddamn minds to choose it as the winner. What chic NY'er would want to wear a bulbous Polynesian shirt?

Stella - she gets my vote just because she did something other than a flirty little dress. Nothing great, but it stood out for being different.

Leanne - Gorgeous skirt. And she was smart to make the top simple because the end result looked like what people do when they take a runway piece and mix it into their wardrobe, it was an outfit instead of a runway look. She was ROBBED!

Emily - Carmen Miranda would love it....so would Santino.

Jennifer - kind of frumpy, looks a bit Erin Fetherston.

Jerrell - boy needs to tame that ego cause so far his stuff sucks. That was just a poorly made Zac Posen gown.

Joe - the top was ok, and you could see the inspiration. The skirt didn't fit, and the little piece of tulle flying off the back didn't add anything.

Blayne - that kid needs to stop looking at all the pretty colors.

Daniel - It was pretty good, nothing spectacular but it definitely looked like his photo.

Kelli - I kinda liked it actually. It wasn't pretty or cute, it had a bit of edge.

Suede - Baby Phat.
Click to expand...
I don't need to say anything because you took every word right out of my mouth. Kenley's was hideous! I mean, I can handle an ugly print, because sometimes when the print is intentionally garish, the design of the dress balances the intensity of the print (several Lacroix pieces come to mind). But Kenley's was so ugly and the tulle was such a HUGE mistake...colored tulle hardly ever works.

Except...I liked the design of Terri's, but I didn't like the print. And I kind of liked Keith's....
Although, I'm finding a lot of the designer's outfits looks SO much better on the dress form.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
^^I just realized that I said I didn't need to say anything because you took the words right out of my mouth...and then a write a pretty hefty post!:lol:
 
I don't know names yet, but I can say that the girl who got sent home...

her dress was GORGEOUS! I instantly fell in love with it. :heart:

Maybe the ruffles were misplaced just a bit, but the idea was breath-taking.
 
CallItTreason said:
The other way around? I don't think Emily's dress was bad, but winning material? Noway.
Click to expand...

I don't know if you're responding to my post, but if you are, let me explain myself a bit. I don't think Emily deserved to win. I said Leanne should have won. BUT, given the choice between Kenley and Emily, I'd say Emily deserved the win and Kenley deserved to be kicked out. That was the worst fabric choice Kenley could've made (actually Terri might have beat her there) and the design wasn't even THAT great. And I don't understand what's so bad about Emily's design. Not the best by any means, but deserving of cut? No.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There are way too many designers this year.
I can't keep anyone straight.
I just realized last night there are 2 mousy brunettes, not 1.

I don't understand why everyone hates Stella. I love her!!!
I wouldn't wear any of her clothes myself but she is damn good at what she does.
That being said she maybe shouldn't bet on winning PR b/c they don't want a biker chic look everytime and that seems to be what she is giving them.

As much as I love Kenley I didn't think she deserved the win. Her dress was butt ugly, IMO.
I loved Leann's and would wear it in a second. She should have gotten the win.

Emily's dress was so very amateur. Very Forever 21 which is never a good thing.
I am not sad to see her go, she didn't stand out to me.

When Teri was describing what she was going to do I thought I would hate it but ended up really liking it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Threads

Z
Project Runway Season 9
9 10 11 12 13
Replies
245
Views
29K
valliaddict
V
P
Project Runway Season 6
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
150
Views
21K
Erin
E
Z
Project Runway Season 8
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
130
Views
14K
Erin
E
C
Project Runway Season Four
34 35 36 37 38
Replies
747
Views
61K
floatingworld
F
F
'Project Runway' Is a Project, but Doesn't Lead to Runway
2
Replies
38
Views
7K
smartarse
S

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)

New Posts

Forum Statistics

Threads
212,523
Messages
15,187,939
Members
86,407
Latest member
ashleyeleanorh

Share This Page

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "058526dd2635cb6818386bfd373b82a4"
<-- Admiral -->